Diagnostic HRCT criteria for usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP) pattern - ATS/ERS/JRS/ALAT (2018)
As a part of international evidence-based guidelines adopted by a collaborative effort of the American Thoracic Society (ATS), the European Respiratory Society (ERS), the Japanese Respiratory Society (JRS), and the Latin American Thoracic Association (ALAT), specific diagnostic HRCT criteria for usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP) pattern were adopted in 2011 and reviewed in 2018.
In 2018, the Fleischner Society has also published a white paper on the approach for the HRCT diagnosis of usual interstitial pneumonia: diagnostic HRCT criteria for usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP) pattern - Fleischner society guideline (2018).
On this page:
Overview
- the guideline is intended to help clinicians make an accurate diagnosis of IPF and to empower them to implement recommended courses of action, particularly decisions in which diagnostic intervention to pursue
- the guideline applies for the patterns and distribution assessed on HRCT chest
- these criteria have been shown to have moderate interobserver reliability among thoracic radiologists 4
Classification
- UIP pattern (definite)
- probable UIP pattern
- indeterminate for UIP pattern
- alternative diagnosis
This helps radiologists to determine the certainty of usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP) diagnosis based on HRCT chest findings. The importance of this guideline is that (definite) UIP pattern on chest HRCT precludes the need for tissue diagnosis 1,2,5. However, unfortunately up to 20% of inconsistent with UIP group (or actually atypical UIP) can be UIP on biopsy or progress clinically to a diagnosis idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF).
UIP pattern
Classic HRCT pattern including:
- honeycombing: it is the distinguishing feature of UIP and must be present
- reticular abnormalities
- distribution: subpleural with a basal predominance
- absence of features suggestive of an alternative diagnosis
Probable UIP pattern
HRCT studies with absent honeycombing, but showing:
- reticular abnormalities
- +/- ground-glass opacification superimposed on a fine reticular pattern (cf. pure ground-glass opacities, which is not a typical UIP feature)
- peripheral traction bronchiectasis or traction bronchioloectasis
- distribution: subpleural with a basal predominance
- absence of features suggestive of an alternative diagnosis
Indeterminate for UIP pattern
HRCT features of pulmonary fibrosis that do not meet the "UIP" or "probable UIP" patterns above and does not explicitly suggest an "alternative diagnosis".
- subtle reticular abnormalities
- +/- ground glass opacification superimposed on a fine reticular pattern (cf. pure ground-glass opacities, which is not a typical UIP feature)
- distribution: do not suggest any specific etiology
This category includes those patients with very limited subpleural reticulation or ground-glass opacities without other obvious features of pulmonary fibrosis and for whom there is some suspicion for an early UIP or probable UIP.
Alternative diagnosis
Where imaging is performed with clinical suspicion for IPF, but HRCT findings are either suggestive of another etiology (e.g. hypersensitivity pneumonitis, NSIP, sarcoidosis) 5:
- distribution
- upper or mid lung predominance
- peribronchovascular or perilymphatic
- marked mosaic attenuation (air trapping), predominant ground-glass opacification
- profuse micronodules, centrilobular nodules
- pleural changes
- effusions
- thickening or plaques (consider asbestosis)
Other ancillary findings even in the presence of UIP pattern changes should prompt consideration of an alternative diagnosis: dilated esophagus (consider connective tissue disease), distal clavicular erosions (consider rheumatoid arthritis), extensive lymph node enlargement.
Previous versions
In 2018 the guidelines were reviewed 5, and the main changes compared to the 2011 publication are:
- "possible UIP" no longer exists and has been replaced by "probable UIP"
- studies have shown that most of these patients were likely to have histopathologic UIP pattern despite the radiologic absence of honeycombing
- similar to the diagnostic HRCT criteria for usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP) pattern - Fleischner society guideline (2018), this reviewed guidelines moved from three to four HRCT categories with a reasonable correspondence among the two 2018 papers
- now, the patient's management should be based on their HRCT classification in two groups 5:
- HRCT pattern of probable UIP, indeterminate for UIP, and alternative diagnosis
- HRCT pattern of UIP
See also
Related Radiopaedia articles
Chest
- imaging techniques
-
chest x-ray
-
approach
- adult
- pediatric
- neonatal
-
airspace opacification
- differential diagnoses of airspace opacification
- lobar consolidation
-
atelectasis
- mechanism-based
- morphology-based
- lobar lung collapse
- chest x-ray in the exam setting
- cardiomediastinal contour
- chest radiograph zones
- tracheal air column
- fissures
- normal chest x-ray appearance of the diaphragm
- nipple shadow
-
lines and stripes
- anterior junction line
- posterior junction line
- right paratracheal stripe
- left paratracheal stripe
- posterior tracheal stripe/tracheo-esophageal stripe
- posterior wall of bronchus intermedius
- right paraspinal line
- left paraspinal line
- aortic-pulmonary stripe
- aortopulmonary window
- azygo-esophageal recess
- spaces
- signs
- air bronchogram
- big rib sign
- Chang sign
- Chen sign
- coin lesion
- continuous diaphragm sign
- dense hilum sign
- double contour sign
- egg-on-a-string sign
- extrapleural sign
- finger in glove sign
- flat waist sign
- Fleischner sign
- ginkgo leaf sign
- Golden S sign
- Hampton hump
- haystack sign
- hilum convergence sign
- hilum overlay sign
- Hoffman-Rigler sign
- holly leaf sign
- incomplete border sign
- juxtaphrenic peak sign
- Kirklin sign
- medial stripe sign
- melting ice cube sign
- more black sign
- Naclerio V sign
- Palla sign
- pericardial fat tag sign
- Shmoo sign
- silhouette sign
- snowman sign
- spinnaker sign
- steeple sign
- straight left heart border sign
- third mogul sign
- tram-track sign
- walking man sign
- water bottle sign
- wave sign
- Westermark sign
-
approach
- HRCT
-
chest x-ray
- airways
- bronchitis
- small airways disease
-
bronchiectasis
- broncho-arterial ratio
- related conditions
- differentials by distribution
- narrowing
-
tracheal stenosis
- diffuse tracheal narrowing (differential)
-
bronchial stenosis
- diffuse airway narrowing (differential)
-
tracheal stenosis
- diverticula
- pulmonary edema
-
interstitial lung disease (ILD)
- drug-induced interstitial lung disease
-
hypersensitivity pneumonitis
- acute hypersensitivity pneumonitis
- subacute hypersensitivity pneumonitis
- chronic hypersensitivity pneumonitis
- etiology
- bird fancier's lung: pigeon fancier's lung
- farmer's lung
- cheese workers' lung
- bagassosis
- mushroom worker’s lung
- malt worker’s lung
- maple bark disease
- hot tub lung
- wine maker’s lung
- woodsman’s disease
- thatched roof lung
- tobacco grower’s lung
- potato riddler’s lung
- summer-type pneumonitis
- dry rot lung
- machine operator’s lung
- humidifier lung
- shower curtain disease
- furrier’s lung
- miller’s lung
- lycoperdonosis
- saxophone lung
-
idiopathic interstitial pneumonia (mnemonic)
- acute interstitial pneumonia (AIP)
- cryptogenic organizing pneumonia (COP)
- desquamative interstitial pneumonia (DIP)
- non-specific interstitial pneumonia (NSIP)
- idiopathic pleuroparenchymal fibroelastosis
- lymphoid interstitial pneumonia (LIP)
- respiratory bronchiolitis–associated interstitial lung disease (RB-ILD)
- usual interstitial pneumonia / idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (UIP/IPF)
-
pneumoconioses
- fibrotic
- non-fibrotic
-
lung cancer
-
non-small-cell lung cancer
-
adenocarcinoma
- pre-invasive tumors
- minimally invasive tumors
- invasive tumors
- variants of invasive carcinoma
- described imaging features
- adenosquamous carcinoma
- large cell carcinoma
- primary sarcomatoid carcinoma of the lung
- squamous cell carcinoma
- salivary gland-type tumors
-
adenocarcinoma
- pulmonary neuroendocrine tumors
- preinvasive lesions
-
lung cancer invasion patterns
- tumor spread through air spaces (STAS)
- presence of non-lepidic patterns such as acinar, papillary, solid, or micropapillary
- myofibroblastic stroma associated with invasive tumor cells
- pleural invasion
- vascular invasion
- tumors by location
- benign neoplasms
- pulmonary metastases
- lung cancer screening
- lung cancer staging
-
non-small-cell lung cancer